Fiber-Reinforced Thermoplastic Sucker Rods Provide Artificial Lift Efficiencies

Abstract

_ This article, written by JPT Technology Editor Chris Carpenter, contains highlights of paper IPTC 23949, “Fiber-Reinforced Thermoplastic Sucker Rods Providing High-Strength, Lightweight, Low-Cost, and Environmentally Responsible Artificial Lift Efficiencies,” by Jeff Saponja, SPE, Oilify, and Corbin Coyes, SPE, and Michael Conner, SPE, Q2 Artificial Lift Services. The paper has not been peer reviewed. Copyright 2024 International Petroleum Technology Conference. _ The complete paper focuses on the development of fiber-reinforced thermoplastic (FRTP) sucker rods, highlighting their potential advantages and challenges, for rod pumping (in general) and for offering an earlier transition from electrical submersible pump (ESP) pumping or gas lifting to reliable deep high-rate rod pumping. A unique feature of an FRTP composite rod is its remarkably high shear failure resistance compared with that of a thermoset composite rod. A high shear-failure resistance means the rods have compressional loading tolerance and that an entire sucker rod string could be comprised of FRTP sucker rods. Introduction Sucker rods made from steel are relatively heavy. Extensive well-specific designs require tapering of rod strings to optimize the overall sucker rod string weight relative to the strength and fatigue requirements and consideration of the dynamic loadings from accelerations and decelerations of the rods and fluids, frictional effects, and structural or power limitations of the pump jack or unit at surface. Steels suffer from corrosion risks. Corrosion, which rapidly can accelerate fatigue failure, often is the root cause of sucker rod failure. Fiber-reinforced composites (i.e., fibers surrounded by or wetted by a resin matrix) have gained considerable popularity because they can be tailored to have outstanding mechanical, thermal, and physical properties, and have superior material mechanical properties to metal. The fatigue behavior of composite materials and structures is complex because composites fail by a series of, or collection of, damage mechanisms, including fiber breakage, matrix cracking, fiber/matrix debonding, delamination, and the effect of shear-induced damage on cracks. Cracking can be slowed somewhat if the reinforced fibers are of high stiffness. Composite materials can offer a lower environmental footprint over their entire life cycle. They can require less energy to manufacture, thereby reducing CO2 emissions. A high strength/weight ratio offers less energy consumption during operational use, further reducing CO2 emissions. Composite materials can be recycled and reused. Composite sucker rods, in the form of thermoset fiberglass sucker rods, have offered a high strength/weight ratio with greater corrosion tolerance, but they are too stretchy from a low glass fiber tensile modulus of elasticity for deep high-rate rod pumping and when a high production-rate decline is likely. This limitation results in a large bottomhole pump-stroke variability as operating conditions change. Such rods have low tolerance to compressional and impact loads, forcing a larger proportion of a sucker string to remain as steel. They are also more costly than steel rods. For sucker rod pumping, an ideal composite rod should tolerate compressional loads and feature high impact resistance and high fatigue endurance with an ability to limit or control crack formation. A composite material that potentially offers these important sucker rod properties is FRTP.