Fentanyl analog structure-activity relationships demonstrate determinants of diverging potencies for antinociception and respiratory depression

Abstract

Opioid overdoses, particularly those involving fentanyl-related substances (FRS), present a significant public health challenge in the United States. This structure-activity relationship (SAR) study evaluated the relationship between the chemical structure of seventeen FRS and their in vivo mu-opioid-receptor (MOR) mediated effects. SAR evaluations included fluorine substitutions on the aniline or phenethyl ring and variations in N-acyl chain length. Adult male Swiss Webster mice were administered fluorinated regioisomers of fentanyl, butyrylfentantyl and valerylfentanyl, and compared to MOR standards including morphine, buprenorphine, and fentanyl to determine if they would elicit prototypical opioid-like effects including hyperlocomotion (open-field test), antinociception (warm-water tail-withdrawal test), and hypoventilation (whole-body plethysmography test). To determine if the MOR was the pharmacological mechanism responsible for these effects, naltrexone or naloxone pretreatments were administered to evaluate their actions on FRS-induced antinociception and hypoventilation. There were three main findings. First, FRS elicited hyperlocomotion, antinociception, and hypoventilation in mice to varying degrees, similar to prototypical MOR standards. Second, the rank order of potencies for hypoventilatory effects of FRS were different for each series including FRS with increasing N-acyl chain length (i.e., acetylfentanyl, fentanyl, butyrylfentanyl, valerylfentanyl, hexanoylfentanyl), phenethyl-fluorinated regioisomers (e.g., 2′-fluorofentanyl, 3′-fluorofentanyl, 4′-fluorofentanyl), and aniline-fluorinated regioisomers (e.g., ortho-fluorofentanyl, meta-fluorofentanyl, para-fluorofentanyl). Third, the degree of separation in potencies observed for the antinociceptive and hypoventilatory effects of these drugs did not always follow that which was observed for their antinociceptive and hyperlocomotor effects. This study clarifies the in vivo activities for these FRS and elucidates a SAR for MOR-mediated effects among structural isomers.