Feasibility study and material selection for powder-bed fusion process in printing of denture clasps

Abstract

Background and objectiveThe retention of selective laser melting (SLM)-built denture clasps is inferior to that of cast cobalt-chromium (Co–Cr) clasps engaging 0.01-in undercuts, which are commonly used in clinical practice. Either the clasps engage in excessively deep undercuts or inappropriate printing process parameters are applied. With appropriate undercut engagement and levels of process parameters, the retention of SLM-built clasps (including Co–Cr, commercially pure titanium [CP Ti], and Ti alloy [Ti–6Al–4V] ones) may be comparable to that of cast Co–Cr clasps. Therefore, this feasibility study aimed to evaluate their retention to guide dentists during material selection for the powder-bed fusion process during the printing of denture clasps. MethodsWe engaged the clasp arm at an appropriate undercut depth (0.01 or 0.02 in), built clasps at the orientation of their longitudinal axes approximately parallel to the build platform, generated square prism support structures at a critical overhang angle of 30°, applied optimized laser parameters (laser power, scan speed, and hatch space), and adopted annealing treatment for Co–Cr, CP Ti, and Ti–6Al–4V clasps. After postprocessing and accuracy measurement, an insertion/removal test of the clasps for 15,000 cycles was performed to simulate 10 years of clinical use, and the retentive force was recorded every 1500 cycles. Permanent deformation of the retentive arms of the clasps was measured. Cast Co–Cr clasps engaging 0.01-in undercuts were designated the control group. ResultsThe initial retentive forces of the SLM-built Co–Cr clasps engaging 0.01-in undercuts and CP Ti and Ti–6Al–4V clasps engaging 0.02-in undercuts were comparable to those of the control group. SLM-built Co–Cr clasps engaging 0.01-in undercuts and Ti–6Al–4V clasps engaging 0.02-in undercuts had similar final retentive force and less permanent deformation compared with those of the control group; SLM-built CP Ti clasps engaging 0.02-in undercuts had lower final retentive force and greater permanent deformation. ConclusionsConsidering the long-term retention and permanent deformation of the retentive arms, Co–Cr and Ti–6Al–4V alloys, except CP Ti, are recommended for printing denture clasps. SLM-built Co–Cr clasps should engage 0.01-in undercuts, and Ti–6Al–4V clasps should engage 0.02-in undercuts.