Fatal Childhood Injury Patterns in an Urban Setting

Abstract

Study objective: To describe fatal childhood injury patterns in an urban county and evaluate the use of the emergency medical services system. Design: Retrospective chart review of medical examiner files, prehospital and hospital records, and police and fire personnel reports. Setting: Milwaukee County, Wisconsin, an urban county with a population of approximately 1 million. Participants: All children 15 years old or younger who sustained a fatal injury in 1989 or 1990 (70). Results: House fires were the leading cause of death by injury (34%), followed by firearms (19%), and drowning (11%). Motor vehicle occupant deaths occurred less frequently (7%). One-third of deaths were homicides (48% firearms and 30% assault). Twenty-four percent of deaths were pronounced at the scene, 12% were dead-on-arrival (no emergency department resuscitative efforts), and 37% were dead-on arrival ED resuscitations. Only 27% of victims survived to become inpatients (84% died within 72 hours). Mean scene time (16.1 ± 7.9 minutes), transport time (9.5 ± 5.1 minutes), and success rates for prehospital peripheral IV insertion (72%), endotracheal intubation (91%), and intraosseous line (86%) were not significantly different among those who were dead-on-arrival, dead-on-arrival failed resuscitations, or eventual inpatients. Conclusion: Fatal childhood injury patterns in this urban setting differed from reported national injury patterns. This study found a higher percentage of deaths from fire, gunshot wounds, and homicides but a lower percentage of motor vehicle-related deaths. Prevention strategies need to address the injury patterns of a particular community. Only a small percentage of victims survived to receive inpatient care following their injuries, suggesting that primary prevention of injury may be the most effective intervention. [Weesner CL, Hargarten SW, Aprahamian C, Nelson DR: Fatal childhood injury patterns in an urban setting. Ann Emerg Med February 1994;23:231-236.]