Factors Influencing Surgical Choices in Breast Cancer Treatment in India: A Comparative Study of Breast-Conserving Surgery vs Mastectomy.

Abstract

Background Breast-conserving surgery (BCS) can make breast cancer treatment less disfiguring and more aesthetically acceptable for women. However, very few patients in India chose to undergo BCS surgery despite eligibility. Therefore, this study aims to explore the factors influencing the surgical choice in the treatment of breast cancer in India. Materials and methods This prospective study was conducted at a tertiary care hospital in Central India. Women having stage I/ II breast cancer diagnosis with a tumor size <5 cm were considered. A detailed self-designed questionnaire was used. A chi-square test with a significance level (p-value <0.05) was applied. Results Out of 40 females, 80% (n = 32) chose modified radical mastectomy (MRM), whereas 20% (n = 8) opted for BCS. The primary motivations to undergo MRM included concern about cancer recurrence (30%, n = 12), desire to avoid the adverse effects of radiation therapy (25%, n = 10), and fear of radiation therapy (20%, n = 8). Surgeons play a dominant role in determining surgical options, with 80% of MRM cases following the surgeon's recommendation. A significant association was observed between surgical options, education, economic status, locality, and family history (p<0.001). Changes in decision-making regarding the type of surgery after admission to the hospital were significant (p<0.001) after counseling. Conclusions The choice between breast conservation and mastectomy is influenced by sociodemographic factors, personal views, and surgeons' recommendations. Thus, these factors must be considered in preoperative counseling to help patients make informed choices.