Abstract

Building performance and material change of cultural heritage in urban areas are negatively impacted by wind-driven rain (WDR). The frequency and intensity of WDR exposure are modified by climate change. Current approaches to exposure assessment emphasise prolonged exposure. Here, we propose indices to represent the exposure of cultural heritage to extreme WDR events. The indices are derived in two stages: (1) time-binning of long-term exposure, and (2) statistical representation of the occurrence of infrequent but intense events by fitting to the Generalised Extreme Value (GEV) distribution. A comparison to an existing exposure assessment procedure demonstrates that the proposed indices better represent shorter, more intense, and more consistent WDR events. Indices developed for seasons had greater statistical confidence than those developed for annual exposure. One index is contextualised within a model of a gutter on a terraced building: this converts the index from a measure of exposure to potential impact. This evaluation demonstrated the importance of maintenance to reduce the potential impact of WDR events. This work has direct and indirect implications for developing robust assessment procedures for cultural heritage exposure to extreme weather events.

Highlights

  • Masonry walls have a high moisture content and are inherently wet to a greater or lesser extent.Historic masonry walls and their mortars have the ability to absorb and evaporate moisture provided foundations are not permanently saturated by rising damp or walls wetted by ineffective guttering.These effects, and the risk from wind-driven rain, were highlighted in a study of Brodick Castle, a 13th century sandstone Category A listed building on the Isle of Arran [1]

  • The study reported on the effects on wall moisture content of the failure of lead guttering and while adequate and well maintained rainwater disposal systems are at the heart of historic building protection, the increase in extreme episodic wind-driven rain events has highlighted the importance of impact indices and risk assessment to effective building maintenance and urban heritage management

  • These indices are derived from extreme value analysis, one of which is contextualised in a model of gutter overflow to represent potential impact on built heritage

Read more

Summary

Introduction

Masonry walls have a high moisture content and are inherently wet to a greater or lesser extent. Historic masonry walls and their mortars have the ability to absorb and evaporate moisture provided foundations are not permanently saturated by rising damp or walls wetted by ineffective guttering These effects, and the risk from wind-driven rain, were highlighted in a study of Brodick Castle, a 13th century sandstone Category A listed building on the Isle of Arran [1] The time-binning procedure is outlined, the output of which is compared to the intensity and temporal characteristics of indices in current use These indices are derived from extreme value analysis, one of which is contextualised in a model of gutter overflow to represent potential impact on built heritage. The discussion that follows emphasises the combined use of these indices and contextualisation as a tool for comparative evaluation of impact assessment

Regional Case Study
A Demonstrative Example
Temporal Characteristics of the Time-Binned Events
Consistency
Seasonal Characteristics
GEV Fitting
Threshold Assessment
Empirical Approaches to Wind-Driven Rain
Urban Complexity
Seasonality
Direct Exposure Assessment
Future Work and Outcomes
Determination of Wind-Driven Rain Exposure
Existing Rules for Prolonged Exposure
Proposed Rules for Extreme Events
Index Selection
Extreme Value Analysis
Impact Assessment
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call