Exploring Why Birth Center Clients Choose Hospitalization for Labor and Birth

Abstract

ObjectiveTo identify demographic and clinical factors associated with birth center clients electing hospitalization for labor and birth and to explore the timing and rationale for elective hospitalization via health records. DesignA secondary analysis of multiyear data from a quality assurance project at a single birth center. We compared two subsamples—birth center preference group and hospital preference group—and described the apparent rationale for transfers among clients in the latter group. SettingA single freestanding birth center where all midwives have admitting privileges at a local hospital and can accompany labor transfers. ParticipantsAll cases included in the analytic sample represent women with low-risk pregnancies who were eligible for birth center birth. The birth center preference group represents clients planning to give birth at the center, and the hospital preference group consists of clients who elected for hospitalization. MeasurementsRelevant demographic and clinical information was provided for the entire analytic sample and was matched with available data collected systematically by birth center staff via chart review. The data set also included anonymous responses to an e-mailed questionnaire from clients identified by birth center staff. ResultsApproximately 56.1% (N = 1,155) of the cases in the data set were eligible for comparative analysis. The birth center preference and hospital preference groups included 899 (77.8%) and 256 (22.2%) individuals, respectively. In the hospital preference group, Black clients (n = 23), those who were publicly insured (n = 49), and primiparas (n = 101) were significantly overrepresented. Chart review data and questionnaire responses highlighted insurance restrictions, family preferences, pain relief options, and postpartum care as influential factors among members of the hospital preference subsample. ConclusionThe present analysis shows associations between certain individual characteristics and elective hospitalization during labor for birth center clients. Health record data and questionnaire responses indicated a variety of reasons for electing hospitalization, illustrating the complexity of clients’ decision-making during pregnancy and birth.