Explicit-by-Implicit Treatment of Natural Orbital Occupations Using First- and Second-Order Optimization Algorithms: A Comparative Study.

Abstract

To address the convergence issues in the natural occupation optimization of reduced density matrix functional theory (RDMFT), we recently proposed the explicit-by-implicit (EBI) idea to handle the ensemble N-representability constraint (Yao et al. J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2021, 12, 6788). This work continues to focus on these issues that can affect the reliability of the electronic structure description in RDMFT; further explores the combination of EBI, as well as the (augmented) Lagrangian methods (both LM and ALM), with both first- and second-order numerical optimization algorithms; and carefully evaluates their performances in natural occupation optimizations of various systems, including strongly correlated systems and large molecules. By comparing both converged energies and elapsed times, it can be seen that the LM and ALM have serious convergence issues for systems of different sizes. In contrast, the optimizations of EBI can converge to better energies with fewer iterations. However, due to the local convergence nature of the Newton's Method (NM) algorithm, EBI@NM still suffers from the local minimum issue for both strongly correlated systems and large molecules. Overall, the combination of EBI with the simple first-order algorithm of gradient descent (GD), namely EBI@GD, consistently provides the lowest converged energies for different types of systems, with the lowest computational scaling. These tests demonstrate the advantages of EBI in the calculations of transition states, strongly correlated systems, and large molecules. Meanwhile, the insights gained from this work are helpful to further develop more efficient algorithms for RDMFT.