Experimental investigation of dynamic stability of a cantilever pipe aspirating fluid

Abstract

The dynamic stability of a submerged cantilever pipe conveying fluid from the free end to the fixed one is considered as one of the unresolved issues in the area of fluid–structure interaction. There is a contradiction between theoretical predictions and experiments. Reported experiments did not show any instability, while theory predicts instability beyond a critical fluid velocity. Recently, several papers appeared, improving the theoretical modelling of pipe dynamics. All theories predict instability, either oscillatory or static, referred to here as flutter and divergence, respectively. A new test set-up was designed to investigate the hypothesis that previous experimental set-ups could not allow observations of pipe instability or the pipe aspirating water is unconditionally stable. In this new test set-up, the fluid velocity could exceed the theoretically predicted critical velocities. A cantilever pipe of about 5 m length was partly submerged in water. The free open end of the pipe was in the water, whereas the fixed end was above the waterline. The experiments clearly showed that the cantilever pipe aspirating water is unstable beyond a critical velocity of water convection through the pipe. Below this velocity the pipe is stable, whereas above it the pipe shows a complex motion that consists of two alternating phases. The first phase is a nearly periodic orbital motion with maximum amplitude of a few pipe diameters, whereas the second one is a noise-like vibration with very small amplitudes. Increasing the internal fluid velocity results in a larger amplitude of the orbital motion, but does not change the pipe motion qualitatively.