Experimental comparisons of different cryogenic fracturing methods on coals

Abstract

Hydraulic fracturing using water-based fracturing fluids is widely used in coalbed methane (CBM) reservoir development. However, the stimulation efficiency of conventional hydraulic fracturing in CBM reservoir is low. Liquid nitrogen (LN2) cryogenic fracturing is one possible method to improve the stimulation efficiency. To test the feasibility of the LN2 cryogenic fracturing, laboratory fracturing tests were conducted to investigate the performances of different LN2 cryogenic fracturing methods in this paper. The breakdown pressure and fracture morphology of water fracturing, LN2 direct fracturing, LN2 freeze fracturing, LN2 freeze-thaw fracturing and LN2 compound fracturing were compared. And the mechanisms of different cryogenic fracturing techniques are revealed. The results demonstrate that thermal damage caused by LN2 freezing is the main reason for the complicated fracture pattern in cryogenic fracturing. LN2 freeze-thaw fracturing has the lowest breakdown pressure and can create the most complex fractures among these cryogenic fracturing methods due to the huge thermal damage. LN2 freeze fracturing has the highest breakdown pressure. Because the thermal damage cracks and natural fractures in frozen rock are in freezing shrinkage, which activation are difficult. LN2 compound fracturing is the most potential technologies, which can produce more complex fracture networks than water fracturing and LN2 fracturing.