Excised Femoral Heads in Hip Fracture Patients: Is Osteoporosis Worse Than Cancer?

Abstract

IntroductionAnnually 80,000 hip fractures are treated at an estimated cost of two billion pounds. The 2011 guidance from the Royal College of Pathologists recommended all specimens where there is fracture through or below the articular surface should be examined to exclude/ identify an underlying cause (pathological fracture). The questions posed in this study are three-fold. Firstly, how does our practice for hip fracture patients comply with the above audit standards? Secondly, what is the prognostic significance of a past medical history of malignancy on survival? Thirdly, is there any other prognostic survival difference attributable to the diagnosis concluded from the histological analysis of the excised femoral head specimens?MethodsA retrospective analysis of all hip fractures receiving joint arthroplasty was undertaken between January 2011 and March 2014. Mortality was recorded for a minimum follow-up of 30 months post-operatively. Each excised femoral head was histologically examined by a single consultant histopathologist, and all pre-operative X-rays were reviewed by a consultant radiologist. Histological diagnoses were recorded, and statistical analysis including Kaplan-Meier survival was performed.ResultsA total of 327 consecutive fractures were identified. Out of 187 specimens sent for analysis, only two revealed metastatic deposits in patients with known disseminated malignancy. A previous medical history of malignancy did not confer a significant increase in mortality over a five-year postoperative period (p = 0.42). A histological diagnosis of osteoporosis significantly increased mortality over a five-year postoperative period (p = 0.004). A comparative analysis found that patients with a histological diagnosis of osteoporosis had the poorest survival.ConclusionA histological femoral head analysis may diagnose previously undiagnosed osteoporosis, allowing the clinician to intervene in a disease process, which if left untreated, can lead to a significant increase in mortality.