Examining Racial Disparities in Multiple Myeloma Research and Treatment

Abstract

Multiple myeloma (MM) is a disease which occurs in all races, geographic locations, and ethnicities, however the burden of this cancer is especially prominent in the African American/Black population with prevalence estimated to be as high as two to three times that of the White population. As a result MM is the most common hematological malignancy in Black patients. Despite a higher disease burden, this population suffers disproportionate rates of mortality. From 2017-2022 Black men had a 6% higher incidence rate than White men, but a 19% higher mortality rate. This disparity in outcomes between ethnic groups is likely multifactorial. Some explanations include novel therapy underutilization, or prevalence of comorbid conditions. It may also be attributable to biological differences, such as an increase rate of immunoglobin A disease, and an increased rate of chromosome 14 translocations. There may as a result be a heterogenous response to novel MM therapy. Unfortunately, clinical trial participation of Black patients has been significantly underrepresented. Studies that sought to analyze the results of novel therapy trials in this population found a trend towards decreased efficacy, however, were unable to reach significance due to insufficient study participation. We conducted a pooled analysis of interventional phase III clinical trials obtained from ClinicalTrials.gov data from 01/01/2000 to 12/31/2022. Studies who did not include racial/ethnicity data were excluded. There were 34 trials included in total that met this criteria and included in this analysis. There were 16,405 total enrolled patients analyzed. 13,618 (83.01%) were White, 1,255 (9.21%) were Asian, 777 (4.74%) were Black/African American, and 454 (2.7%) identified as Hispanic, with the remaining identified as other. Study participation was analyzed over time. Percentage of patients enrolled by year showed a negative correlation in Black/African Americans over the analyzed period. Our analysis suggests greater efforts need to be made to ensure the enrollment of a more diverse and representative MM population. Although this disease is roughly twice as prevalent in Black populations, clinical trial study participation since 2003 involved 18-times more White than Black patients. Despite ongoing recognition of this problem, study participation in MM has continued to remain largely homogenous. Interventions that may improve this problem include fostering and rebuilding trust in the clinical trial system that was damaged from historical abuses, expanding clinical sites to more diverse areas, expanding/revising eligibility criteria, and employing changes to enrollment techniques that better represent the demographics of the population intended to treat. Ultimately, the clinical trials for an intervention should appropriately reflect the population who will use it, otherwise these novel treatments may have unexpected heterogeneity in efficacy and safety once employed clinically.