Evidence of a spatial auto-correlation in the browsing level of four major European tree species.

Robert Hagen,Rudi Suchant

doi:10.1002/ece3.6577

Abstract

The contribution of spatial processes to the spatial patterns of ecological systems is widely recognized, but spatial patterns in the ecology of plant‐herbivore interactions have rarely been investigated quantitatively owing to limited budget and time associated with ecological research. Studies of the level of browsing on various tree species reported either no spatial auto‐correlation or a small effect size. Further, the effects of disturbance events, such as hurricanes, which create large forest openings on spatial patterns of herbivory are not well understood.In this study, we used forest inventory data obtained from the federal state of Baden‐Württemberg (Southern Germany) between 2001 and 2009 (grid size: 100 × 200 m) and thus, after hurricane Lothar struck Southern Germany in 1999. We investigated whether the browsing level of trees (height ≤ 130 cm) in one location is independent of that of the neighborhood.Our analyses of 1,758,622 saplings (187.632 sampling units) of oak (Quercus), fir (Abies), spruce (Picea), and beech (Fagus) revealed that the browsing level is characterized by a short distance spatial auto‐correlation.The application of indicator variables based on browsed saplings should account for the spatial pattern as the latter may affect the results and therefore also the conclusions of the analysis.

Highlights

Tree recruitment in the northern Hemisphere has been impacted by large herbivores for thousands of years (Sommer, Fahlke, Schmölcke, Benecke, & Zachos, 2009), anthropogenic changes may be the most important recent factor affecting forest development (Tinner et al, 2013; Whitlock, Colombaroli, Conedera, & Tinner, 2017) and ungulate density (Bradshaw, Hannon, &Lister, 2003) as well as the relationship between them
Among the approaches developed to quantify the utilization of forest plants by large herbivores (Aldous, 1944; Reimoser, 2000) was that of Zai (1964), who in 1964 proposed a determination of the percentage of browsed trees as a robust index of roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) browsing
The decrease in Moran's I for fir, spruce and beech throughout the period 2001–2009 likely reflected ecological processes initiated by hurricane Lothar in 1999

Summary

Introduction

Tree recruitment in the northern Hemisphere has been impacted by large herbivores for thousands of years (Sommer, Fahlke, Schmölcke, Benecke, & Zachos, 2009), anthropogenic changes may be the most important recent factor affecting forest development (Tinner et al, 2013; Whitlock, Colombaroli, Conedera, & Tinner, 2017) and ungulate density (Bradshaw, Hannon, &Lister, 2003) as well as the relationship between them. 3. Our analyses of 1,758,622 saplings (187,632 sampling units) of oak (Quercus), fir (Abies), spruce (Picea), and beech (Fagus) revealed that the browsing level is characterized by a short distance spatial auto-correlation.

Results

Conclusion