Evaluation of the Goss-modified solvation parameter model for the characterization of biphasic systems and descriptor assignments

Abstract

The solvation parameter model uses six descriptors identified as excess molar refraction, E, dipolarity/polarizability, S, overall hydrogen-bond acidity, A, overall hydrogen-bond basicity, B, McGowan's characteristic volume, V, and the gas-liquid partition constant on hexadecane at 25 °C, L to model the distribution of neutral compounds in biphasic systems. Abraham's version of this model uses all six descriptors with two separate linear free energy relationship models for the transfer of compounds from a gas phase to a condensed phase and between condensed phases. Goss proposed a modification to this model that uses a single calibration model regardless of the physical state for each phase and five of the descriptors employed in Abraham's model (E descriptor is eliminated). The capability of Abraham's model and the Goss-modified model to characterize the contribution of intermolecular interaction to retention for gas and reversed-phase liquid chromatographic systems and distribution in liquid-liquid partition systems is evaluated using the WSU compound descriptor database. These more accurate values for the Abraham descriptors have not been utilized previously for the evaluation of the Goss-modified model and should be more capable of discerning subtle differences in model performance. It is shown that model quality defined by statistical parameters favors Abraham's model over the Goss-modified model with differences in model quality greater for systems in which Abraham's model indicates a significant contribution from electron lone pair interactions and for systems in which one phase is a solvent containing perfluoroalkyl substituents. There is a small systematic difference for the terms describing the combined contributions of cavity formation and dispersion interactions and for interactions of a dipole-type. The contribution of hydrogen-bonding interactions is virtually identical for the two models. The model intercepts are generally different and potentially assigned to a larger contribution from lack-of-fit for the Goss-modified model. Although the Abraham model descriptors have been routinely employed for applications using the Goss-modified model the possibility that Goss-model specific descriptors should be employed was evaluated. Using the Solver method and Goss-model specific calibration models for chromatographic and liquid-liquid partition systems a new set of Goss-specific descriptors was calculated for 28 varied compounds. These descriptors show good statistical agreement with the Abraham descriptor values with an average deviation of 0.009, -0.003, -0.004, and -0.023, respectively, for the S, A, B, and L descriptors, corresponding to a relative absolute deviation in percent of 2.2 %, 3.9 %, 4.3 %, and 1.2 %, respectively.