Evaluation of Strong Consistency Web Caching Techniques

Abstract

The growth of the World Wide Web (WWW or Web) and its increasing use in all types of business have created bottlenecks that lead to high network and server overload and, eventually, high client latency. Web Caching has become an important topic of research, in the hope that these problems can be addressed by appropriate caching techniques. Conventional wisdom holds that strong cache consistency, with (almost) transactional consistency guarantees, may neither be necessary for Web applications, nor suitable due to its high overhead. However, as business transactions on the Web become more popular, strong consistency will be increasingly necessary. Consequently, it is important to have a comprehensive understanding of the performance behavior of these protocols. The existing studies, unfortunately, are ad hoc and the results cannot be compared across different studies. In this paper we evaluate the performance of different categories of cache consistency algorithms using a standard benchmark: TPC-W, which is the Web commerce benchmark. Our experiments show that we could still enforce strong cache consistency without much overhead, and Invalidation, as an event-driven strong cache consistency algorithm, is most suitable for online e-business. We also evaluate the optimum deployment of caches and find that proxy-side cache has a 30–35% performance advantage over client-side cache with regard to system throughput.