Evaluation of carbonate diagenesis: A comparative study of minor elements, trace elements, and rare-earth elements (REE + Y) between Pleistocene corals and matrices from Grand Cayman, British West Indies

Abstract

On Grand Cayman, the Pleistocene Ironshore Formation consists of six unconformity-bounded units of limestones that have been partially or completely altered to calcite by post-depositional meteoric diagenesis. In order to examine the diagenetic history from the perspective of geochemical elements, the concentrations of minor element (Sr, Na, Mg), trace elements (Ba, Fe, Mn, Al, Si), and rare-earth elements (REE) and yttrium (Y) were determined for 105 corals and 84 matrices collected from the Rogers Wreck Point (RWP), Western Onshore area (WO), and offshore George Town (GT) areas. With the transformation of aragonite to calcite, the Sr, Na, and Ba values decreased, but Mg increased, which are indicative of diagenetic alteration in an open water system. Due to intrinsic “vital effects” and the extrinsic diagenetic environment, the variations of Sr, Na, Ba, and Mg concentrations between Acropora and Montastrea from the GT area are different to those of their counterparts from RWP and WO. The signatures of Sr, Na, Ba, and Mg are in good agreement with the diagenetic history as determined from petrographic and stable isotopic criteria.The REE+Y (REY) concentrations (ΣREY) are higher in the matrices (0.2–6.9ppm, average 2.6ppm) than in the associated corals (0.1–5.4ppm, average 0.6ppm). Shale-normalized REY patterns of the Pleistocene Ironshore Formation are similar to those of oxygenated seawater, which are characterized by (1) light REE depletion relative to heavy REE (average DySN/SmSN=1.7, n=35), (2) positive La anomalies (average Pr/Pr*=1.17, n=53), and (3) negative Ce anomalies (average Ce/Ce*=0.49, n=53). The preserved seawater-like REY distribution pattern, the lack of correlation between ΣREY and mineralogy, and the lack of correlation between ΣREY and diagenesis-sensitive stable oxygen isotope (δ18O) indicate that meteoric diagenesis did not have a major impact on the REY distribution patterns. The matrices and corals in the GT area, compared to their counterparts from RWP and WO, have relatively less depleted LREE and lower Y in REY distribution pattern, suggesting contamination by minor amounts of detrital sediments. This is supported by the fact that limestones from the GT area contain abnormally high contents of detrital elements (Al, Si). The variations in ΣREY in carbonate rocks from locality to locality probably reflect variations that existed in the local depositional environments where these deposits originally formed.