Evaluation of CALGRID using two different ozone episodes and comparison to UAM results

Abstract

Air quality models serve as the foundation for policy decisions regarding programs designed to improve air quality. The California Air Resources Board Airshed Model (CALGRID) is one of the latest photochemical air quality models developed for assessing ozone control strategies. CALGRID was modified to include the lates CBIV chemical mechanism in place of the original SAPRC mechanism. After modification, a detailed evaluation of CALGRID was carried out using two different ozone episodes. The first evaluation used data obtained during the Southern California Air Quality Study (SCAQS). The second evaluation used data obtained for the September, 1984 SCCCAMP episodes in the South Central Coast Air Basin (SCCAB). Model results were compared against observations of O 3, NO, NO 2, and different organic compounds. For the SCCAB episode, the results were also compared with those obtained from the Urban Airshed Model (UAM). Similar to other studies, the ozone predictions from the SCAQS application were biased low, as were various ROG components. The reason for this can be linked to the under-representation of ROG and CO in the emissions inventory. For the SCCAB episode, both the UAM and CALGRID models significantly underestimated NO and NO 2 concentrations. The two models slightly underestimated ozone concentrations above approximately 9 pphm on the third and last day of the simulation. Sensitivity experiments were performed for both the studies. It was found that both CALGRID and UAM are strongly sensitive to the boundary conditions and moderately sensitive to the emissions for the episodes modeled.