EVALUATION OF AN OGAWA MYCOBACTERIUM CULTURE METHOD MODIFIED FOR HIGHER SENSITIVITY EMPLOYING CONCENTRATED SAMPLES

Abstract

Two egg-based culture media were evaluated for detection of mycobacteria with Lowenstein-Jensen (L-J) as a gold standard. The conventional culture method was modified to improve laboratory diagnosis of tuberculosis in resource scarce countries by employing an inexpensive but sensitive and specific culture method. Sputum samples were collected from pulmonary tuberculosis suspects who visited the chest clinic at the University Teaching Hospital in Zambia. These samples were processed using three different sample treating procedures (with or without sample concentration) and cultured on L-J and Ogawa media for mycobacteria isolation. A total of 276 sputum samples were collected from 138 pulmonary tuberculosis suspects. When the L-J result was used as a standard, the sensitivity of Ogawa and modified Ogawa was 81.7% and 90.3% respectively. Similarly, the specificities of those methods were 96.7% and 92.3% respectively. In total, 90 samples (32.6%) were smear positive and 108 (39.1%) were culture positive. The positivity of each culture method was as follows: 93 (33.7%) in L-J, 98 (35.5%) in modified Ogawa, and 82 (29.7%) in original Ogawa. The contamination rate was 1.1%, 5.1%, and 9.8% for L-J, Ogawa and modified Ogawa respectively. The Ogawa culturing method is economical, simple and quick. Its low sensitivity was overcome by employing the concentration method, the sensitivity significantly improving from 81.7% to 90.3%. Ogawa techniques are ideal in overburdened TB laboratories with poor resources in developing countries.