Evaluation of a Novel Female Gender Flexible Ureteroscope: Comparison of Flow and Deflection to a Standard Flexible Ureteroscope.

Abstract

Introduction: The advent of single-use disposable flexible ureteroscopes allows for rapid prototyping of novel endoscopes. In this regard, we sought to develop a female-specific ureteroscope, with a shorter working length, to account for the female anatomy. We hypothesized that the shorter, female-specific single-use flexible ureteroscope would engender higher irrigation flow at a given pressure than that of the standard-length ureteroscope. Methods: An in vitro analysis of a standard 65 cm Dornier Axis™ ureteroscope and a shorter, 45 cm female-specific Dornier Axis ureteroscope was performed. All other aspects of the endoscopes were identical. Each ureteroscope was oriented vertically and connected to a Thermedx® irrigation system to provide uniform pressurized flow. The average flow rate was computed over five, 2-minute periods at pressure settings of 50, 100, 150, and 200 mm Hg. Data were collected with the working channel unoccupied, after placement of a 200 μm (0.6F) holmium laser fiber and after passage of a 1.7F stone basket. The procedure was then repeated with the endoscopes at maximum deflection. Results: The female gender ureteroscope had significantly higher irrigation flow rates than the standard-length ureteroscope under all conditions by an average of 11% (p < 0.02). The highest average percent increase, 17% (p < 0.001), was seen with the 1.7F NGage® basket in the working channel with the endoscope straight. The maximum angle of deflection was not significantly different between the female gender and standard ureteroscopes with an open working channel (314° vs 315°, p = 0.86), with the 1.7F NGage basket in place (314° vs 315°, p = 0.15), and with the 200 μm holmium laser in place (316° vs 309°, p = 0.09). Conclusions: A 45 cm female gender ureteroscope allows for a higher irrigation flow rate than the standard-length ureteroscope under all test conditions. There is no added benefit with regard to deflection capabilities.