Evaluation of a genotoxicity test measuring DNA-strand breaks in mouse lymphoma cells by alkaline unwinding and hydroxyapatite elution

Abstract

A rapid genotoxicity test, based on the measurement of the proportion of single- to doulbe-stranded DNA by alkaline unwinding and hydroxyapatite elution in mouse lymphoma cells treated in vitro with various chemicals, was evaluated. Seventy-eight compounds from diverse chemical groups, including commonly tested mutagens, toxic compounds not usually tested for genotoxicity and non-toxic compounds not thought to be genotoxic were tested. The results obtained were compared with those from the mouse lymphoma TK locus forward-mutation assay, providing a basis for assessing the relative sensitivity of the 2 assays using the same cells exposed to chemicals under similar conditions. Clear evidence of DNA-damaging activity was obtained with 43 of the compounds, while 4 gave equivocal results. Of the remaining 31 compounds, 14 were toxic without inducing DNA damage while the rest were non-toxic and did not induce any DNA damage. Results were available from both the alkaline unwinding assay and the mouse lymphoma assay for 61 compounds; they showed a concordance between the 2 assays of 77%. Of the 47 compounds that were positive or equivocal in the alkaline unwinding assay, only carbon tetrachloride and prednisolone were negative in the mouse lymphoma assay, while 12 of the 19 compounds that were negative in the alkaline unwinding assay were positive in the mouse lymphoma assay. These included 3 compounds that interfere with nucleic acid metabolism, and 3 crosslinking agents, which would be expected to produce mutations to a greater extent than strand breaks. the other 6 compounds were anthranilic acid, benzoquinone, p-chloroaniline, diethylmaleate, glucose and procarbazine HCl. Of these only the last is a known carcinogen. It is concluded from the present study that there was good overall agreement between the results of the DNA alkaline unwinding and mouse lymphoma TK locus assays, but that the sensitivity of the alkaline unwinding assay is lower for some classes of compounds. Bearing this in mind, the alkaline unwinding assay is considered suitable as a rapid screen for genotoxic activity in eukaryotic cells.