Evaluation of 2 refractometers to estimate different passive immunity status in Simmental dairy calves

Abstract

Inadequate transfer of passive immunity (ITPI) is major risk for mortality, morbidity and decreased growth performance in dairy and beef calves. Refractometry method is used in estimating ITPI in dairy and beef calves but studies evaluating refractometers for Simmental dairy calves are limited. The objectives of this study were determining the accuracy of digital serum total protein refractometer (STP-REF) and digital Brix refractometer (BRIX-REF) in the estimating of different passive immunity status (<10, <18, <25 and <32 g/L) in Simmental dairy calves. Serum samples were collected from apparently healthy Simmental dairy calves aged 1–8 days (n = 291). Serum total solid percentages were measured using BRIX-REF, serum total protein concentrations were measured using STP-REF and serum IgG concentrations were measured using radial immunodiffusion (RID) assay as a reference test. Correlation coefficients were calculated between RID test and refractometers results, and each other. The diagnostic test performance of the refractometers at IgG concentrations of < 10, < 18, < 25 and < 32 g/L was measured by performing a receiver operating characteristics (ROC) analysis. The optimal thresholds of the refractometers were determined based on Youden's J statistics and after accounting for different costs between false positive and false negative cases using misclassification cost term analysis. The overall test performance and the agreement of the refractometers were assessed using area under the ROC curve and Cohen's kappa analysis. Optimal thresholds were determined as < 7.9, < 8.3, < 8.7, < 9.4% for the BRIX-REF, and < 4.6, < 5.2, < 5.4, < 5.8 g/dL for the STP-REF in estimating IgG concentrations of < 10, < 18, < 25, < 32 g/L, respectively. Se and Sp of BRIX-REF were 88.8% and 89.1% for < 7.9% Brix, 81.6% and 94.2% for < 8.3% Brix, 77.9% and 97.4% for < 8.7% Brix and 81.7% and 91.2% for < 9.4% Brix, respectively. Se and Sp of STP-REF 92.5% and 88.2% for < 4.6 g/dL; 92.1% and 87.1% for < 5.2 g/dL; 81.7% and 93.6% for < 5.4 g/dL; 79.0% and 94.1% for < 5.8 g/dL, respectively. Both, digital Brix and STP refractometers performed well to estimate the status of passive immunity in dairy Simmental calves.