Evaluating the usefulness of the direct density reconstruction algorithm for intensity modulated and passively scattered proton therapy: Validation using an anthropomorphic phantom.

Abstract

Accurate calculation of the proton beam range inside a patient is an important topic in proton therapy. In recent times, a computed tomography (CT) image reconstruction algorithm was developed for treatment planning to reduce the impact of the variation of the CT number with changes in imaging conditions. In this study, we investigated the usefulness of this new reconstruction algorithm (DirectDensity™: DD) in proton therapy based on its comparison with filtered back projection (FBP). We evaluated the effects of variations in the X-ray tube potential and target size on the FBP- and DD-image values and investigated the usefulness of the DD algorithm based on the range variations and dosimetric quantity variations. For X-ray tube potential variations, the range variation in the case of FBP was up to 12.5mm (20.8%), whereas that of DD was up to 3.3mm (5.6%). Meanwhile, for target size variations, the range variation in the case of FBP was up to 2.2mm (2.5%), whereas that of DD was up to 0.9mm (1.4%). Moreover, the variations observed in the case of DD were smaller than those of FBP for all dosimetric quantities. The dose distributions obtained using DD were more robust against variations in the CT imaging conditions (X-ray tube potential and target size) than those obtained using FBP, and the range variations were often less than the dose calculation grid (2mm). Therefore, the DD algorithm is effective in a robust workflow and reduces uncertainty in range calculations.