Evaluating bottom-up forcing of a rocky intertidal resource harvest on a high trophic-level consumer group

Abstract

The importance of ecosystem-based management (EBM) frameworks for resource harvest has increased over the past several decades as ecosystems face numerous anthropogenic stressors. In these frameworks, resource managers must consider the suite of interactions that comprise food webs and how resource harvest drives responses in non-target organisms. In rocky intertidal zones along North Atlantic coastlines, rockweed (Ascophyllum nodosum)—a canopy-forming brown seaweed—has been commercially harvested for centuries, yet most research on the effects of harvest have focused on the responses of the target resource and the macroinvertebrate assemblage. In this study, we used a Before-After Control-Impact experiment to assess the bottom-up effects of commercial rockweed harvest on a high trophic-level consumer group (birds) in Maine (USA). Overall, there was no evidence for strong bottom-up forcing of rockweed harvest on birds' site visitation. There was a small (fewer than two birds) positive effect size of harvest during the one-year post-harvest recovery interval. Several of the trends observed for the full bird assemblage appear to be driven more strongly by the low tide than the high tide bird assemblage. Independent of treatment, site visitation by birds was low in our study (60% of surveys recorded no birds) and highlights questions about the use of rocky intertidal habitats relative to other habitat types in coastal birds' home ranges. To our knowledge, there are no comparable assemblage-level bird studies in this system that can provide context to our results. Further research on coastal birds’ habitat use within home ranges and food-web connections with rockweed-associated macroinvertebrates is needed to more confidently incorporate this high trophic-level consumer group into an EBM framework for a rocky intertidal resource harvest.