Estimating temporal and spatial changes in soil organic carbon stocks and its controlling factors in moraine landscapes in Denmark

Abstract

Assessing temporal changes in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks is important when evaluating the SOC sequestration potential of soil management strategies. The monitoring of SOC stocks is challenging, particularly in eroding landscapes where erosion-induced changes in SOC stocks are superimposed on changes related to management. In this study we focused on the spatio-temporal variations of SOC in eroding cropland soils of the northeast of thepeninsulaofJutland (Denmark) at field scale. We examined soil redistribution processes as control factors of SOC changes (ΔSOC) during a 16-year period by using soil data (both spatial and with depth) collected over two distinct periods in 1998 and 2014. Topographic changes between 1998 and 2014, derived from high resolution digital elevation models, were used to identify eroded, stable and depositional areas within the field. There was a predominance of soil loss, with 44% of the sampling points corresponding to eroded sites and 28% to depositional sites, while the remainder was considered as stable soils. Substantial erosion was detected and at the field scale, soil deposition equalled (29.7 ± 17.5 Mg ha−1 y−1) while soil erosion rates were lower with a mean of 25.8 ± 12.9 Mg ha−1 y−1. Comparing SOC stocks over the 16 year-period showed that on average, and when considering the whole soil profile, SOC contents and stocks were stable. However, this masked substantial dynamics that were related to erosion processes. Despite the occurrence of net soil erosion at the field scale, there was an overall increase in SOC storage of 1.88 Mg ha (SOC2014:SOC1998 ratio ≥ 1). Losses of SOC in topsoils (6%) and SOC gain (34%) in soil layers below the plough depth (25–45 cm) could be related to soil disturbances caused by tillage and the significant downward transport of topsoil SOC within the soil profile. Soil disturbances caused by tillage practices (i.e. soil management) and SOC transportation from topsoil to subsoil may be responsible for the downward movement of organic carbon and consequent SOC accumulation in subsoils. In addition the successive deposition and deep burial of SOC rich topsoils at depositional sites due to the effect of topography and slope position favours the enrichment of SOC in subsoils. It was estimated that as much as 11% of the sampling points changed from eroded to depositional sites and 15% of them varied from erosion to stable sites, and this might have favoured SOC accumulation. These results clearly show that understanding and quantifying soil redistribution processes is key to assess SOC temporal changes in agricultural soils. This is important to develop site-specific management strategies that improve SOC sequestration at local scale.