ESR and mass-spectrometric uranium-series dating studies of a mammoth tooth from stanton harcourt, Oxfordshire, England

Abstract

The age of the Channel Deposits at Stanton Harcourt, Oxfordshire, England, has been a topic of debate with important implications for British Pleistocene stratigraphy. Recent excavations led by K. Scott reveal ample evidence for ancient environmental conditions characteristic of an interglacial. However, the question remains on the assignment of its age. At present it is thought to represent an interglacial corresponding to either marine OI Stage 7 or 5e. In an attempt to constrain the chronology of the site, and to assess the techniques' reliability, we have made electron spin resonance (ESR) measurements on enamel and mass-spectrometric U-series measurements on both enamel and dentine from a mammoth tooth buried in the Channel Deposits at Stanton Harcourt. Four dentine samples gave U-series dates between 65.4±0.4 and 146.5±1.0 ka and two enamel samples between these dentine layers were dated to 53.3±0.2 and 61.1±0.6 ka. The corresponding ESR age estimates for the enamel samples are 59±6 and 62±4 ka (early U-uptake, EU) and 95±11 and 98±7 ka (linear U-uptake, LU). The recent U-uptake (RU) dates are 245±38 and 238±31 ka, but in light of the U-series data we would not expect these to represent realistic age estimates. Similar ESR results were obtained from two other adjacent enamel samples. The effect of the large size of the mammoth tooth on the external gamma dose, and the internal gamma contribution from the high U content of the dentine, are considered. While the recent uptake ESR dates appear to coincide with OI Stage 7, all the early and linear uptake ESR and mass-spectrometric U-series dates are younger than the expected age estimation based on recent geological interpretation and amino acid racemisation measurements (>200 ka) and optical dating studies (200–450 ka). Possible causes of the unexpected dating results are discussed. We conclude that our mass-spectrometric U-series and EU and LU ESR measurements represent minimum age estimates for the tooth analysed. Our results seem to suggest that the tooth and hence the Channel Deposits are at least 147 ka in age. i.e. predating the last interglacial.