Erosional effects on soil organic carbon stock in an on-farm study on Alfisols in west central Ohio

Abstract

Soil erosion and depositional processes in relation to land use and soil management need to be quantified to better understand the soil organic carbon (SOC) dynamics. This study was undertaken on a Miamian soil (Oxyaquic Hapludalfs) under on-farm conditions in western Ohio with the objectives of evaluating the effects of degree of erosion on SOC stock under a range of tillage systems. Six farms selected for this study were under: no-till (NT) for 15, 10, 6 and 1.5 years; chisel till every alternate year with annual manure application (MCT); and annual chisel till (ACT). A nearby forest (F) site on the same soil was chosen as control. Using the depth of A horizon as an indicator of the degree of erosion, four erosion phases identified were: uneroded (flat fields under F, NT15, and on the summit of sloping fields under NT10, NT6, NT1.5 and MCT); deposition (NT10, NT6, NT1.5 and ACT); slight (NT10, MCT and ACT); and moderate erosion (NT10 and ACT). Core and bulk soil samples were collected in triplicate from four depths (i.e., 0–10, 10–20, 20–30 and 30–50 cm) for each erosional phase in each field for the determination of bulk density, and SOC concentrations and stocks. SOC concentration in NT fields increased at a rate of 5% year −1 for 0–10 cm and 2.5% year −1 for 10–20 cm layer with increasing duration under NT. High SOC concentration for NT15 is indicative of SOC-sequestration potential upon conversion from plow till to NT. SOC concentration declined by 19.0–14.5 g kg −1 in MCT and 11.3–9.7 g kg −1 in NT10 between uneroded and slight erosion, and 12.0–11.2 g kg −1 between slight and moderate erosion in ACT. Overall SOC stock was greatest in the forest for each of the four depths. Total SOC stock for the 50 cm soil layer varied in the order F (71.99 Mg ha −1) > NT15 (56.10 Mg ha −1) > NT10 (37.89 Mg ha −1) = NT6 (36.58 Mg ha −1) for uneroded phase ( P < 0.05). The lack of uneroded phase in ACT indicated high erosion risks of tillage, as also indicated by the high SOC stock for deposition phase from 0 to 50 cm soil layer (ACT (56.56 Mg ha −1) > NT1.5 (42.70 Mg ha −1) > NT10 (30.97 Mg ha −1)). Tillage increased soil erosion and decreased SOC stock for top 10 cm layer for all erosional phases except deposition.