Equity factors in pediatric transplant listing: Initial findings from a single center review.

Abstract

In order to improve transparency within the patient selection process, a transplant listing advisory committee was formed within the Boston Children's Hospital Pediatric Transplant Center. Its mission is to promote equity in access to organ transplantation by ensuring that the institutional transplant selection criteria are fair, unbiased, and nondiscriminatory. The committee conducts comprehensive case and data review of individual characteristics and reviews in aggregate to identify potential systems bias. Charts for 256 patients evaluated for transplant from 3/2016 to 3/2019 were reviewed. Among these, 64 (25%) patients were declined for transplant. Univariate logistic regression analysis was used to identify demographic variables and vulnerable status factors associated with being declined. Odds ratios (OR) are reported. Among all patients, median age was 8.5 years and 58% were male. Asian patients were more likely to be declined than White patients (OR=5.3, Wald p=.007). Socioeconomic factors that affected likelihood of listing decline included concerns for caregivers' ability to manage and understand care requirements (OR=3.8, p=.011), caregiver employment status (OR=1.9, p=.042), and use of public assistance programs (OR=2.2, p=.05). Patients with severe neurodevelopmental delay were more likely to be declined for listing (OR=3.7, p=.019). This analysis identified areas of potential bias related to race, socioeconomic status, and neurodevelopmental delay where initiatives can be targeted. Advisory committees are an important aspect of evaluating equity in transplant center selection policy and practice.