Environmental Risk of Pesticides for Fish in Small- and Medium-Sized Streams of Switzerland.

Inge Werner,Helmut Segner,Marion Junghans,Anke Schneeweiss

doi:10.3390/toxics9040079

Abstract

This study assessed the acute and chronic risk of pesticides, singly and as mixtures, for fish using comprehensive chemical data of four monitoring studies conducted in small- and medium-sized streams of Switzerland between 2012 and 2018. Pesticides were ranked based on single substance risk quotients and relative contribution to mixture risk. Concentrations of the pyrethroid insecticides, λ-cyhalothrin, cypermethrin and deltamethrin, and the fungicides, carbendazim and fenpropimorph, posed acute or chronic single substance risks. Risk quotients of eighteen additional pesticides were equal or greater than 0.1, and thirteen of those contributed ≥30% to mixture risk. Relatively few substances dominated the mixture risk in most water samples, with chronic and acute maximum cumulative ratios never exceeding 5 and 7, respectively. A literature review of toxicity data showed that concentrations of several pesticides detected in Swiss streams were sufficient to cause direct sublethal effects on fish in laboratory studies. Based on the results of our study, we conclude that pesticides detected in Swiss streams, especially pyrethroid insecticides, fungicides and pesticide mixtures, pose a risk to fish health and can cause direct sublethal effects at environmental concentrations. Sensitive life stages of species with highly specialized life history traits may be particularly vulnerable; however, the lack of toxicity data for non-model species currently prevents a conclusive assessment across species.

Highlights

Contamination of surface water bodies with pesticides has been reported around the world [1,2] and attributed primarily to agricultural and, to a lesser extent, urban sources [3].In Switzerland, several long-term monitoring studies conducted between 2012 and 2018 detected high numbers and concentrations of pesticides in small- and medium-sized streams predominantly flowing through agricultural land [4,5,6]
The fish-specific risk assessment revealed a total of 23 relevant pesticides with RQi ≥ 0.1
In 2018, two other pyrethroids, cypermethrin and deltamethrin, were detected at concentrations exceeding the chronic risk threshold (RQi,chronic ≥ 1)

Summary

Introduction

In Switzerland, several long-term monitoring studies conducted between 2012 and 2018 detected high numbers and concentrations of pesticides in small- and medium-sized streams predominantly flowing through agricultural land [4,5,6]. Between 100 and 145 pesticides were detected (corresponding to 40–67% of analytes), with 19–32 substances exceeding acute or chronic risk thresholds. Analyses of pyrethroid insecticides (previously not analyzed) in 2017 and 2018 showed that these substances were present at concentrations exceeding acute and chronic risk thresholds for aquatic organisms [7,8]. Uncertainties with respect to the risk for fish remain, both with respect to the identification of the most fish-relevant pesticides, mixture risk effects and the potential for toxic effects on fish at environmental concentrations

Methods

Results

Conclusion