Environmental pH and compound structure affect the activity of short-chain carboxylic acids against planktonic growth, biofilm formation, and eradication of the food pathogen Salmonella enterica.

Abstract

Short-chain carboxylic acids (SCCAs) that are naturally produced by microbial fermentation play an essential role in delaying microbial spoilage. SCCAs are structurally diverse, but only a few of them are routinely used in food biopreservation. This study investigated the effects of environmental pH and intrinsic properties of 21 structurally different SCCAs on the antimicrobial and antibiofilm activity against Salmonella enterica. Inhibition of SCCA toward planktonic and biofilm growth of S. enterica was higher in an acidic environment (pH 4.5) that is common in fermented products, and for SCCA that possessed both a high acid dissociation strength (pKa) (>4.0) and a positive hydrophobicity [octanol/water partition coefficient (log Kow)]. Crotonic and caproic acids were identified as SCCAs with potential as biopreservatives even at near-neutral pH. SCCA with hydrophilic groups such as lactic acid did not inhibit S. enterica at concentrations up to 50 mM, while SCCA with benzene or methyl groups or a double bond prevented S. enterica growth and biofilm formation. Stimulation of biofilm formation was observed for formic, acetic, and propionic acid close to the minimum inhibitory concentration to reduce 50% of cell density (MIC50) of planktonic cells, and for citric and isocitric acid with an MIC50 of ≥50 mM. The presence of low concentrations of formic and propionic acids during biofilm formation conferred protection during eradication possibly due to a pre-adaptation effect, yet two consecutive acid treatments were successful in eradicating biofilms if the first acid treatment was two- to threefold of the MIC50.IMPORTANCEThis study provides a systematic comparison on the antimicrobial and antibiofilm activity of more than 20 structurally different SCCAs against a common food pathogen. We tested the antimicrobial activity at controlled pH and identified the structure-dependent antimicrobial effects of SCCA without the confounding influence of acidification. The combined effect of pKa and log Kow was identified as an important feature that should be considered when deciding for a specific SCCA in the application as antimicrobial. Our results imply that additional phenomena such as the use of SCCA as substrate and cellular pre-adaption effects have to be taken into consideration. We finally present a two-step treatment as an efficient approach to eradicate biofilms, which can be applied for the disinfection of contact surfaces and manufacturing equipment. Results obtained here can serve as guidelines for application of SCCA to avoid the growth of food pathogens and/or to develop biopreserved food systems.