Environmental impact assessment of municipal solid waste management options using life cycle assessment: a case study.

Abstract

The goal of this study is to use life cycle assessment (LCA) tool to assess possible environmental impacts of different municipal solid waste management (MSWM) scenarios on various impact categories for the study area Dhanbad City, India. The scenarios included in the present study are collection and transportation (denoted as S1); baseline scenario consisting of recycling, open burning, open dumping, and finally unsanitary landfilling without energy recovery (denoted by S2); composting and landfilling (denoted by S3); and recycling and composting followed by landfilling of inert waste without energy recovery (denoted by S4). One ton of municipal solid waste (MSW) was selected as the functional unit. The primary data were collected through sampling, surveys, and literatures. Background data were obtained from Eco-invent data of SimaPro 8.1 libraries. The scenarios were compared using the CML 2 baseline 2000 method, and the results indicated that the scenario S1 had the highest impact on marine aquatic ecotoxicity (1.86E+04 kg 1,4-DB eq.) and abiotic depletion (2.09E+02kg Sb eq.). S2 had the highest impact on global warming potential (9.42E+03kg CO2 eq.), acidification (1.15E+01kg SO2 eq.), eutrophication (2.63E+00kg PO43- eq.), photochemical oxidation (2.12E+00kg C2H4 eq.), and human toxicity (2.25E+01kg 1,4-DB eq.). However, S3 had the highest impact on abiotic depletion (fossil fuels) (2.71E+02MJ), fresh water aquatic ecotoxicity (6.54E+00kg 1,4-DB eq.), terrestrial ecotoxicity (3.36E-02kg 1,4-DB eq.), and ozone layer depletion (2.73E-06kg CFC-11eq.). But S4 did not have the highest impact on any of the environmental impact categories due to recycling of packaging waste and landfilling of inert waste. Landfilling without energy recovery of mixed solid waste was found as the worst disposal alternative. The scenario S4 was found as the most environmentally suitable technology for the study area and recommended that S4 should be considered for strategic planning of MSWM for the study area.