Enhanced Peroxide Fluxes and Radiosensitization in Colorectal Tumors but Not Normal Enterocytes from the Combination of Superoxide Dismutase Mimetics and Pharmacological Ascorbate

Abstract

Selective superoxide dismutase mimetics (DMs), including GC4419 and GC4711, are radiation (RT) modulators which induce opposite effects in tumors and normal tissues and may be ideally suited for locally advanced rectal cancer. However, their tumor radiosensitization effect is limited at RT doses relevant to rectal cancer (2-5 Gy). Over this dose range, they protect normal mucosal tissues, but we and others have shown they do not reliably enhance tumor radiosensitization at doses < 8-15 Gy. We hypothesize that combining DMs and other therapies which also target redox metabolism may effectively sensitize tumors to clinically relevant RT doses for rectal cancer while maintaining their normal tissue sparing effects. Like DMs, pharmacological ascorbate (P-AscH) selectively increases lethal hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) fluxes in tumors, but it does so through distinct mechanisms which are potentially complimentary with DMs (particularly at low RT doses). Human HCT116, SW480, and HT29 colorectal tumor models and non-malignant FHs74 intestinal epithelial cells were used. Clonogenic survival was assessed following single-fraction RT (2-5 Gy) +/- P-AscH (5 pmol/cell) +/- GC4711 (20 µM). Dependency on H202 fluxes was tested by adding bovine catalase with drug and RT treatments. Oxygen consumption in culture media was measured using a Clark electrode. Rectal toxicity was assessed in vivo using IHC in fixed rectal tissues following fractionated, image-guided rectal RT (5-9 Gy x 3). Tumor growth delay was assessed following RT (5 Gy x 3) +/- P-AscH (4 g/kg) +/- GC4419 (10 mg/kg) in animals with unilateral HCT116 flank tumors. Combination therapy with P-AscH and GC4711 potently radiosensitized all tumor lines in vitro whereas neither agent significantly decreased clonogenic survival as a monotherapy. Neither drug nor combination treatment sensitized FHs74 epithelial cells. P-AscH increased oxygen consumption and H2O2 production in culture media and the addition of GC4711 significantly increased both more than P-AscH alone. Co-treatment with exogenous catalase inhibited cancer cell killing with combination therapy +/- RT. In vivo, combination therapy significantly enhanced tumor growth delay and survival. Both agents significantly decreased markers of acute rectal RT injury as monotherapies. Co-treatment with DMs and P-AscH selectively enhanced tumor radiosensitization by increasing oxygen consumption and H202 fluxes even in tumor models which are known to be resistant to oxidative stressors (HT29). In contrast, each agent conferred a radioprotective effect in the rectum. Combination therapy with DMs and P-AscH may represent a novel, potent approach to target dysregulated redox metabolism in colorectal tumors.