Abstract

Thousands of kilometres of power lines exist and more are planned. Ungulates that range over large areas are likely to encounter power lines, but a synthesis of power line effects on ungulates is lacking. Reindeer (Rangifer tarandus tarandus) are suspected to avoid power lines up to distances of 4 km. In contrast, some forest ungulates preferentially forage in power line rights-of-way, cleared areas under power lines. We reviewed the factors that possibly influence avoidance and attraction effects of power lines on ungulates, construct a conceptual framework, and make suggestions on how to mitigate avoidance effects through power line routing and rights-of-way management. Power line construction, noise and electromagnetic fields are possible sources of disturbance, while rights-of-way management influences habitat use under power lines. Disturbance and altered habitat use can induce barrier and corridor effects, thereby influencing connectivity. Species-specific effects influence behavioural disturbance and habitat use. We found little evidence for behavioural disturbance of reindeer or forest ungulates under power lines. Forest ungulates could benefit from browsing in power line rights-of-way if they are managed to provide abundant and preferred forage as well as sufficient cover. However, power lines may facilitate access for hunters and predators. As a precaution, construction of power lines should be avoided in calving areas. To establish a causal relationship between the construction of power lines and potential avoidance, before-after-impact-control studies are recommended. More research is needed to make recommendations for the optimal design of power line networks.   Key words: Power lines, rights-of-way, ungulates, disturbance.

Highlights

  • The transmission network for central grid power lines of at least 220 kV covers about 300,000 km in Europe (European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity, 2012) and 250,000 km in the USA (Abraham, 2002)

  • Deer (Odocoileus spp.), elk (Cervus canandensis) and other ungulates fed in a power line ROW (500 kV, 41 m wide) without signs of disturbance apart from a five-minute motionless period when entering the ROW (Goodwin Jr, 1975)

  • Whitetailed deer browsed a smaller proportion of stems despite higher availability in power line ROW as compared to adjacent forest, except where the abundance of browsed stems exceeded that of the forest approximately six-fold (Mayer, 1976). These results indicate that forest ungulates may be displaced by power line ROW (Table 2), especially when

Read more

Summary

INTRODUCTION

The transmission network for central grid power lines of at least 220 kV covers about 300,000 km in Europe (European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity, 2012) and 250,000 km in the USA (Abraham, 2002). The Norwegian central grid operator Statnett is planning to increase the construction of power lines to 300 km per year by 2020. Cleared areas under power lines (rights-of-way or ROW) are maintained as early- to mid-successional habitats (Bramble and Byrnes, 1982) and provide benefits through additional browse for forest ungulates (Bramble and Byrnes, 1972). The aim of this article is to review the factors that possibly influence avoidance and attraction effects of power lines on ungulates (Tables 1 to 7), set into a conceptual framework (Figure 1). Power lines could disturb ungulates because they are artificial structures that can emit noise, light and electromagnetic fields. Deer (Odocoileus spp.), elk (Cervus canandensis) and other ungulates fed in a power line ROW (500 kV, 41 m wide) without signs of disturbance apart from a five-minute motionless period when entering the ROW (Goodwin Jr, 1975). Energy spent in response to indifferent stimuli may be wasted (Reimers and Colman, 2009)

Result
Findings
Disclosure or conflict of interest
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call