Energy Density of Three Fishes from Minnesota Waters of Lake Superior

Abstract

Energy densities of three salmonine prey species in Lake Superior were determined by bomb calorimetry to examine seasonal trends, differences due to gender and to establish a relation with percent dry weight. These results from April through October for 1992 and 1993 were compared with other studies from the Great Lakes region. Across the 2-year sampling period rainbow smelt Osmerus mordax energy density decreased from April to June and July then significantly increased into September. Lake herring Coregonus artedii energy density was highest in June, decreased significantly by August, and remained stable through October. Bloater C. hoyi energy density was lowest in July, then increased in August and early September before decreasing in late September. There were no significant differences in energy density between males and females for rainbow smelt and lake herring collected on the same date across sampling dates. However, bloater energy density was significantly higher for females than for males on two dates. Energy density estimates for bloater in Lake Superior were lower than those reported from Lake Michigan. Energy density values of rainbow smelt and lake herring fell within the range reported in Lake Michigan and Lake Ontario (rainbow smelt), and from two inland lakes in Minnesota and Lake Mendota, Wisconsin (lake herring). Percent dry weight was a good predictor of energy density (P < 0.001, r 2 = 0.92–0.99) for all three species for both years. Percent dry weight vs energy density was significantly different between years for bloater and lake herring, and was significantly different for all three species compared with populations in other lakes in the Great Lakes Region.