Enantioselectivity of indoxacarb during the growing, processing, and brewing of tea: Degradation, metabolites, and toxicities

Abstract

Chiral pesticides are unique hazardous materials. Here, we systematically studied the potentially harmful products of enantioselective indoxacarb degradation throughout tea growth, processing, and brewing and tested their toxicity to tea geometrid larvae and honeybees. The half-lives of S-indoxacarb and R-indoxacarb during tea growth were 2.6 d and 3.3 d, respectively. There was a trend toward the production of S-indoxacarb from R-indoxacarb. The degradation products IN-JT333, IN-MK638, IN-MF014, and IN-KG433 were also characterized in tea growth and processing and detected. IN-JT333, previously known as a direct insecticidal compound produced by the enzymatic transformation of indoxacarb in insects, was first found in plant samples. The fixation and rolling of green tea and the rolling of black tea were the most important steps that affected indoxacarb and its degradation products. The leaching rates of R-indoxacarb and S-indoxacarb were slightly higher in green tea than in black tea. The maximum leaching rates of IN-MK638 and IN-MF014 during the brewing process reached 89.9% and 94.1%, respectively. Contact toxicity tests with honeybees and tea geometrid larvae in the lab showed that the relative toxicities of the compounds could be ranked as follows: S-indoxacarb > indoxacarb (3S + 1R) ≫ R-indoxacarb. TEST toxicity predictions showed that relative toxicities were ranked IN-KG433 > indoxacarb > IN-JT333 > IN-MK638 > IN-MF014. The toxicity of the degradation product IN-KG433 is higher than that of indoxacarb itself, and its maximum leaching rate is as high as 88.2%. It therefore transfers readily from processed tea to the tea infusion during the brewing process. These findings indicate the need to pay attention to the risk of metabolites and enantiomeric differences and provide new, comprehensive insight into the risk factors for indoxacarb in tea and are relevant to the study of other chiral pesticides.