Empowerment or employment? Uncovering the paradoxes of social entrepreneurship for women via Husk Power Systems in rural North India

Venkata Bandi,Tiia Sahrakorpi

doi:10.1016/j.erss.2021.102153

Abstract

Men continue to dominate the supply-side narratives of energy access projects, leaving an unexplored gap in gendered organizations. To fill this gap, the article utilises interviews with women workers to consider their lived experience working for an energy access-based organisation. Through the use of narrative analysis, this study highlights the importance of socio-cultural contextualisation of social entrepreneurial activities and social missions. It takes a persuasive case-study approach to analysing Husk Power Systems (HPS), which operates primarily in Bihar, India. HPS, a mini grid-based social enterprise, began its operations in Bihar in 2007 with the goal of ameliorating rural Bihar’s energy access problems and secondarily, empowering women through employment opportunities. Drawing on the concepts of women’s empowerment, social inequalities, and intersectionality, this article argues that although HPS provides formal employment opportunities, its presence has not secured long-lasting women’s empowerment in Bihar. As a social enterprise, HPS has limited capacity to reform social inequalities. Although HPS guarantees local job creation, we underscore further exploration of the intersectional dimensions influencing social enterprises’ energy access business operations’ longevity and impact, including those of local systems of power, caste, gender, and class.

Highlights

Gender’s importance in energy access projects and programs is widely acknowledged in academic literature [1]
This study aims to highlight the importance of socio-cultural contextualisation of social entrepreneurial activities and social mis sions, and the use of an intersectional approach involving women’s empowerment by taking a persuasive case-study approach to analysing Husk Power Systems (HPS), which operates primarily in Bihar, India
Our analysis provides an ethnographic interview-based case study of HPS that employs a narrative analysis of interviews conducted with eight women and 15 men, and two women-only focus groups with five women in each group

Summary

Introduction

Gender’s importance in energy access projects and programs is widely acknowledged in academic literature [1]. Our article focuses on the empowerment of women from a gendered organizational perspective, as it relates to energy access projects. It defines women’s empowerment as a means of achieving gender equality, through the three interconnected dimensions of re sources, agency, and achievements [5,6]. HPS’s mission statement emphasises three social objectives, in addition to rural electrification: women’s empowerment, local employment, and rural development. These missions link closely with the energy justice framework, especially energy poverty and represen tative participation [7]

Objectives

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion