Emotion culture as a resource of sensemaking: Transforming an arson case of a Korean national heritage to citizens’ responsibility

Abstract

This study examines the importance of culture in developing public understanding of social problems. To do so, I analyzed narrative structures of news contents connected to an arson case involving a Korean national heritage, Sungnyemun, in 2008. Scholars have highlighted a character arrangement in a binary opposition (e.g., victim/villain and good/bad) as a common narrative structure when dealing with conflicts. My findings suggest the conventional binary structure does not translate into the case at hand. Instead, the arson case narrative developed through what I conceptualize as binary character convergence. Combining the victim and villain character, news media created a shameful victim character and assigned it to citizens as a whole. As a result, the arson case was transformed into citizens’ collective responsibility. This study shows that cultural particularities of Korean society mediated this process, specifically regarding a conflict resolution practice and shame/apology rituals which are deeply oriented to the value of group harmony. By taking an approach sensitive to cultural contexts, this study contributes to the study of social problem construction, particularly in the examination of a link between a narrative, emotions, and an event.