Abstract
Identification of phenotypic modules, semiautonomous sets of highly correlated traits, can be accomplished through exploratory (e.g., cluster analysis) or confirmatory approaches (e.g., RV coefficient analysis). Although statistically more robust, confirmatory approaches are generally unable to compare across different model structures. For example, RV coefficient analysis finds support for both two- and six-module models for the therian mammalian skull. Here, we present a maximum likelihood approach that takes into account model parameterization. We compare model log-likelihoods of trait correlation matrices using the finite-sample corrected Akaike Information Criterion, allowing for comparison of hypotheses across different model structures. Simulations varying model complexity and within- and between-module contrast demonstrate that this method correctly identifies model structure and parameters across a wide range of conditions. We further analyzed a dataset of 3-D data, consisting of 61 landmarks from 181 macaque (Macaca fuscata) skulls, distributed among five age categories, testing 31 models, including no modularity among the landmarks and various partitions of two, three, six, and eight modules. Our results clearly support a complex six-module model, with separate within- and intermodule correlations. Furthermore, this model was selected for all five age categories, demonstrating that this complex pattern of integration in the macaque skull appears early and is highly conserved throughout postnatal ontogeny. Subsampling analyses demonstrate that this method is robust to relatively low sample sizes, as is commonly encountered in rare or extinct taxa. This new approach allows for the direct comparison of models with different parameterizations, providing an important tool for the analysis of modularity across diverse systems.
Full Text
Topics from this Paper
Macaque Skull
Confirmatory Approaches
Age Categories
Model Structures
Analysis Of Modularity
+ Show 5 more
Create a personalized feed of these topics
Get StartedTalk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Similar Papers
Water Resources Research
Sep 1, 2013
Mar 4, 2021
Water Resources Research
Oct 1, 1998
Mar 28, 2022
Journal of Hydrology
Oct 1, 2004
Water Resources Research
Sep 1, 2020
Journal of Biological Chemistry
Dec 1, 2007
Jan 1, 2018
Dec 12, 2011
Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic
Jan 1, 1985
Water Resources Research
May 1, 2021
Proceedings of the Edinburgh Mathematical Society
Aug 5, 2010
Journal of The London Mathematical Society-second Series
Feb 1, 2008
European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences
Feb 5, 2008
Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
May 21, 2013
Evolution
Evolution
Nov 25, 2023
Evolution
Nov 24, 2023
Evolution
Nov 24, 2023
Evolution
Nov 15, 2023
Evolution
Nov 14, 2023
Evolution
Nov 11, 2023
Evolution
Nov 11, 2023
Evolution
Nov 11, 2023
Evolution
Nov 8, 2023