Elevation-related differences in female mate preference in mountain chickadees: are smart chickadees choosier?

Abstract

Heterogeneous environments are often associated with differential selection pressures favouring the evolution of local adaptations, and assortative mating is one of the mechanisms that might enhance such local adaptations. Montane environments present an example in which environment changes rapidly and predictably along an elevation gradient, and such variation may be expected to lead to the evolution of local adaptations. In food-caching mountain chickadees, Poecile gambeli, reliance on food stores is likely to increase with elevation, and previous research has shown that individuals living at high elevations cache more food and have superior spatial memory, needed to recover food caches, while also being socially subordinate to low-elevation birds. Here, we asked whether such differences might be associated with assortative mating. Considering that superior spatial memory ability for recovering food caches may be more critical for survival at high elevations because of more severe winter conditions, it should benefit females from high elevations to mate assortatively with males from the same elevation. If spatial memory is costly but not critical at low elevations, females from low elevation should mate assortatively with males from low elevation, especially given their socially dominant status to high-elevation birds. We assessed female preference using a pairwise choice of high- and low-elevation males. We used the amount of time spent in proximity to males from the same versus different elevation to determine female preference. High-elevation females showed significant preference for high-elevation males, however, low-elevation females showed no elevation-related preference. These results suggest that high-elevation females are choosier than low-elevation females, and prefer males from their same elevation.