Elaborate Mimetic Vocal Displays by Female Superb Lyrebirds

Anastasia H Dalziell,Justin A Welbergen

doi:10.3389/fevo.2016.00034

Anastasia H Dalziell, Justin A Welbergen

Open Access

https://doi.org/10.3389/fevo.2016.00034

Copy DOI

Abstract

Some of the most striking vocalizations in birds are made by males that incorporate vocal mimicry in their sexual displays. Mimetic vocalization in females is largely undescribed, but it is unclear whether this is because of a lack of selection for vocal mimicry in females, or whether the phenomenon has simply been overlooked. These issues are thrown into sharp relief in the superb lyrebird, Menura novaehollandiae, a basal oscine passerine with a lek-like mating system and female uniparental care. The spectacular mimetic song display produced by courting male lyrebirds is a textbook example of a sexually selected trait, but the vocalizations of female lyrebirds are largely unknown. Here, we provide the first analysis of the structure and context of the vocalizations of female lyrebirds. Female lyrebirds were completely silent during courtship; however, females regularly produced sophisticated vocal displays incorporating both lyrebird-specific vocalizations and imitations of sounds within their environment. The structure of female vocalizations varied significantly with context. While foraging, females mostly produced a complex lyrebird-specific song, whereas they gave lyrebird-specific alarm calls most often during nest defense. Within their vocal displays females also included a variety of mimetic vocalizations, including imitations of the calls of dangerous predators, and of alarm calls and song of harmless heterospecifics. Females gave more mimetic vocalizations during nest defense than while foraging, and the types of sounds they imitated varied between these contexts, suggesting that mimetic vocalizations have more than one function. These results are inconsistent with previous portrayals of vocalizations by female lyrebirds as rare, functionless by-products of sexual selection on males. Instead, our results support the hypotheses that complex female vocalizations play a role in nest defense and mediate female-female competition for breeding territories. In sum, this study reveals elaborate female vocal displays in a species widely depicted as an example of sexual selection for male extravagance, and thus highlights the hidden complexity of female vocalizations.

Highlights

Songbirds have so been named for their elaborate and aesthetically pleasing vocalizations, and until recently (Odom et al, 2014) their ‘songs’ were assumed to be primarily the result of selection on males for attracting mates or repelling rivals (Catchpole and Slater, 2008)
Female superb lyrebirds regularly produced complex and highly varied vocal sounds (Figure 1; Supplementary Audio S2). Comprising both lyrical pure-tone sequences of song-like elements as well as explosive and arresting calls. Within these long and varied bouts, we identified three broad types of vocalizations: (i) characteristic alarm calls unique to lyrebirds (Figure 2), (ii) a lyrebird-specific multi-element song (Figure 3), and (iii) imitations of other species of bird (Figure 4) (: ‘alarm calls,’ ‘whistle songs,’ and ‘mimetic vocalizations’ respectively: details below)
Lyrebird-Specific Alarm Calls and Whistle Songs Lyrebird-specific alarm calls were highly distinctive in our recordings and were produced by most females (12/15)

Summary

Introduction

Songbirds have so been named for their elaborate and aesthetically pleasing vocalizations, and until recently (Odom et al, 2014) their ‘songs’ were assumed to be primarily the result of selection on males for attracting mates or repelling rivals (Catchpole and Slater, 2008). A recent analysis showed that female song is an ancestral trait in the oscine passerines (Odom et al, 2014), adding weight to earlier suggestions that the contemporary research focus on species that have little or no song in females has led to a distorted perspective on the sex-specificity of elaborate vocalizations in birds (Langmore, 1998; Hall, 2004; Riebel et al, 2005). Some of the most complex songs produced by male oscines around the globe incorporate imitations of heterospecifics Such ‘vocal mimics’ include European starlings Sturnus vulgaris (Eens, 1997), marsh warblers Acrocephalus palustris (Dowsett-Lemaire, 1979), northern mockingbirds Mimus polyglottos (Gammon and Altizer, 2011), Lawrence’s thrush Turdus lawrencii (2010), and chorister robins Cossypha dichroa (Harcus, 1977). We provide the first investigation into the mimetic and non-mimetic vocalizations given by females of one of the world’s best-known and most versatile vocal mimics, the superb lyrebird, Menura novaehollandiae

Methods

Results

Conclusion