Abstract

Introduction. As part of the Bologna process since September 1, 2016, the Russian government has granted the right to award academic degrees to leading educational and scientific organizations on par with Dissertation Defense Councils under Higher Attestation Commission, modeled after the system adopted at OECD member-states and universities. Currently, 27 educational and scientific organizations are exercising this right. However, the problematic issue is the assessment of their efficiency. The purpose of this research is to analyze the efficiency of Dissertation Councils of the above-mentioned scientific and educational organizations by comparing them in terms of efficiency with classical Dissertation Defense Councils established by the decree of the Ministry of Education and Scie nce of Russia. Materials and Methods. The research objects are Dissertation Councils of scientific and educational organizations of higher education (hereinafter referred to as pilot organizations) that have the right of independent award of academic degrees according to the Federal Law No. 148 issued on May 23, 2016 “On Amendments to Article 4 of the Federal Law ‘On research and state scientific and technological policy’”. Dissertation Councils efficiency analysis is made using following indicators: Dissertation Councils members’ compliance with the Higher Attestation Commission requirements, structure of candidate and doctoral defenses, Dissertation Councils members’ publications and publication activity of degree seekers. Statistical data analysis methods were applied including mean comparison me thods, clustering, factor analysis. Results. There are 337 pilot Dissertation Defense Councils and 374 classical Dissertation Defense Councils. In 2016, 24% of defenses were reviewed by pilot councils of the total number of defenses in classical Dissertation Councils of the entire network. In 2018 70 doctoral and 591 candidate defenses in “pilot” councils were held, amounting to 7% of the total number of defe nses in classical Dissertation Councils. Discussion and Conclusion. The article will be useful to the heads of federal authorities making management decisions in the field of training and certification of highly qualified scientific personnel, to the chairmen and scientific secretaries of dissertation councils, as well as to scientific and pedagogical workers carrying out analytical studies in this subject area.

Highlights

  • As part of the Bologna process since September 1, 2016, the Russian government has granted the right to award academic degrees to leading educational and scientific organizations on par with Dissertation Defense Councils under Higher Attestation Commission, modeled after the system adopted at OECD member-states and universities

  • The purpose of this research is to analyze the efficiency of Dissertation Councils of the above-mentioned scientific and educational organizations by comparing them in terms of efficiency with classical Dissertation Defense Councils established by the decree of the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia

  • The research objects are Dissertation Councils of scientific and educational organizations of higher education that have the right of independent award of academic degrees according to the Federal Law No 148 issued on May 23, 2016 “On Amendments to Article 4 of the Federal Law ‘On research and state scientific and technological policy’”

Read more

Summary

Introduction

As part of the Bologna process since September 1, 2016, the Russian government has granted the right to award academic degrees to leading educational and scientific organizations on par with Dissertation Defense Councils under Higher Attestation Commission, modeled after the system adopted at OECD member-states and universities. Материалы и методы Объектом данного исследования являлись диссертационные советы научных организаций и образовательных организаций высшего образования, которым, согласно нормативно-правовым актам, предоставляется право самостоятельного присуждения ученых степеней кандидата и доктора наук. Government.ru/media/files/6fAycV743U5HhewGEi4N7GO44FflqFQQ.pdf (дата обращения: 01.06.2019); О перечне научных и образовательных организаций, которым предоставляется право самостоятельно присуждать ученые степени: Распоряжение Правительства Российской Федерации от 23 августа 2017 г. Российским законодательством установлено, что критерии, которым должны отвечать диссертации, а также требования к научной квалификации членов советов по защите диссертаций, создаваемых самостоятельно организациями на основании локальных нормативных правовых актов, не могут быть ниже аналогичных критериев и требований, установленных в соответствии с нормативными правовыми актами Российской Федерации. Отмечается, что количество публикаций, в которых излагаются основные научные результаты диссертации на соискание ученой степени доктора наук, в научных изданиях, входящих в международные базы данных и системы цитирования, должно быть не менее трех. На рисунке 1 приведены сведения об абсолютном и относительном количестве публикаций соискателей ученой степени кандидата и доктора наук, защитившихся в «пилотных» диссертационных советах по сравнению с лицами, защитившими диссертации в классических диссертационных советах во всей сети

Количество научных
Ioffe Institute
ITMO University
Findings
СПИСОК ИСПОЛЬЗОВАННЫХ ИСТОЧНИКОВ
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call