Efficacy of multipurpose solutions against Acanthamoeba species

Abstract

Aim The disinfection efficacy of contact lens multipurpose solutions (MPSs) against Acanthamoeba polyphaga (Ros) and Acanthamoeba castellanii (ATCC30868) cysts and trophozoites was determined by both biocidal and manufacturer-recommended no-rub/rinse regimen testing. Methods A biocidal assay using four MPSs (ReNu ® with MoistureLoc ®, Opti-free Express, Solo-care Plus, and Complete MoisturePlus) was conducted with or without the presence of organic soil. A second test procedure compared the ability of five MPSs (ReNu with MoistureLoc MPS, ReNu MultiPlus, Opti-free Express, Solo-care Aqua, and Complete MoisturePlus) to remove and kill Acanthamoeba species cysts and trophozoites from SofLens 38 and Surevue conventional hydrogel lenses, and Focus Night & Day silicone hydrogel lenses using the manufacturer-recommended regimen. Results In the biocidal assay, only ReNu with MoistureLoc successfully killed both trophozoites and cysts (>3 log) within the manufacturer-recommended soak time. A >3 log decrease in trophozoites, but not cysts, was reported for Opti-free Express; however, Solo-care Plus and Complete MoisturePlus did not reduce the number of cysts or trophozoites by >3 log during the manufacturer-recommended soak time. In the no-rub/rinse regimen tests, only ReNu with MoistureLoc removed an inoculum of 2 × 10 5 trophozoites or cysts from SofLens 38 and Surevue hydrogel lenses, as well as Focus Night & Day silicone hydrogel lenses. Less than 10 viable organisms were recovered from the lenses after the 10 s rinse and 4 h soak. Opti-free Express, Solo-care Aqua, and ReNu MultiPlus were effective at removing trophozoites and cysts from SofLens 38 and Surevue conventional hydrogel lenses, but not from Focus Night & Day silicone hydrogel lenses. In excess of 10 viable organisms were recovered from all lenses after the manufacturer-recommended regimen using Complete MoisturePlus. Conclusions These data suggest that some MPSs, when used as recommended by the manufacturer, are more effective at killing representative strains of Acanthamoeba than others.