Efficacy of intraoperative radiofrequency ablation (IRFA) combined or not with resection to treat unresectable colorectal metastases, with or without preoperative chemotherapy: The ARF2003 Study (NTC 00210106): Preliminary results

Abstract

4095 Background: Only few patients suffering from colorectal metastases (CRM) can have surgery and thus hope for a 40% 5-year survival rate. Adding IRFA to resection may improve the efficacy of surgery. Methods: The primary objective was to evaluate the efficacy of IRFA combined or not with resection in terms of 3-month complete hepatic response (CHR) in patients with unresectable CRM. Secondary endpoints were overall survival (OS), disease-free survival (DFS), morbidity and quality of life. A phase II study based on a Simon's two-stage design was conducted in 6 university French hospitals. Number of subjects estimated was 53, with 19 for the 1st stage. At the end of the 1st stage, 12 CHR were required to continue recruiting. At the end of 2nd stage, 37 CHR would be required to claim efficacy. Results: Fifteen of the first 19 patients exhibited CHR allowing the study to pursue accrual which ended in Nov 08; some patients are still followed up. As of Nov 08, data had been collected on 47 patients (mean age 61 years): 6 had RFA alone (13%), 37 had RFA and resections (82%), 2 could not be treated (4%). Median number of CRM was 5 (1–12). All had chemotherapy pre-op and 12 post-op (29%). Three-month data were available for 36 patients: 1 patient died on the 3rd week following intervention. Scans were available for 35 patients (independently reviewed). Of these, 29 had CHR (83%); 13 had 3-month morbidity (37%). The median follow-up was 15 months. One-year OS and DFS rates were 92.3% and 26% respectively. Analysis on all 53 patients will be communicated in June 09. Conclusions: These preliminary results suggest that IRFA combined or not to resection may be efficient in treating unresectable diseases despite their more aggressive pattern. This corroborates the EORTCC CLOCC Trial findings which demonstrated IRFA superiority upon chemotherapy alone. IRFA could thus be valuably associated to resection in treating patients with colorectal metastases that resection alone could not handle. No significant financial relationships to disclose.