Abstract

In the COVID-19 pandemic, among the more controversial issues is the use of masks and face coverings. Much of the concern boils down to the question—just how effective are face coverings? One means to address this question is to review our understanding of the physical mechanisms by which masks and coverings operate—steric interception, inertial impaction, diffusion, and electrostatic capture. We enquire as to what extent these can be used to predict the efficacy of coverings. We combine the predictions of the models of these mechanisms which exist in the filtration literature and compare the predictions with recent experiments and lattice Boltzmann simulations, and find reasonable agreement with the former and good agreement with the latter. Building on these results, we explore the parameter space for woven cotton fabrics to show that three-layered cloth masks can be constructed with comparable filtration performance to surgical masks under ideal conditions. Reusable cloth masks thus present an environmentally friendly alternative to surgical masks so long as the face seal is adequate enough to minimize leakage.

Highlights

  • Face coverings have become a common motif of the global response to the COVID-19 pandemic.[1,2,3,4] At the time of writing, 139 countries have mandated the use of face coverings in public spaces such as on public transport, 19 countries mandate coverings on a regional level and a further 17 countries recommend their use.[5]

  • We explore the parameter space for woven cotton fabrics to show that three-layered cloth masks can be constructed with comparable filtration performance to surgical masks under ideal conditions

  • For smaller (0.1 to 3 lm) droplets, the efficacy is dependent on the type of material from which the face covering is comprised, but some materials can achieve excellent protection (! 95%) for տ 1lm droplets, which is comparable to surgical masks

Read more

Summary

INTRODUCTION

Face coverings have become a common (though controversial) motif of the global response to the COVID-19 pandemic.[1,2,3,4] At the time of writing, 139 countries have mandated the use of face coverings (or already practiced universal masking) in public spaces such as on public transport, 19 countries mandate coverings on a regional level and a further 17 countries recommend (but do not require) their use.[5]. SARS-CoV-2 is transmitted primarily by the airborne route, i.e., by direct inhalation of aerosolized particles containing virus.[7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15] Face coverings work to prevent this transmission route by suppressing onwards transmission of the virus on exhalation[16] (so-called “source control”) or to provide protection to the wearer on inhalation, i.e., as personal protective equipment (PPE).

MATERIAL PROPERTIES OF MASKS
Contact forces
Experiments
CAPTURE OF DROPLETS BY A SINGLE FIBRE
Single-fiber efficiency from idealized flows
Kuwabara flow field
Lattice Boltzmann flow field
Particle motion
Particle deposition and collection efficiency
Single-fiber efficiency from combined mechanisms
Specific mechanisms
Droplet inertia rapidly increases efficiency above a threshold value
FROM SINGLE FIBRES TO TOTAL FILTER EFFICIENCY
Filter efficiency from a polydisperse assembly of fibers
Filtration efficiency of nonwoven materials
Correction for pores
Findings
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call