Efficacy of different bioactive glass S53P4 formulations in biofilm eradication and the impact of pH and osmotic pressure

Abstract

AimThe challenging properties of biofilm-associated infections and the rise of multidrug-resistant bacteria are prompting the exploration of alternative treatment options. This study investigates the efficacy of different bioactive glass (BAG) formulations - alone or combined with vancomycin - to eradicate biofilm. Further, we study the influence of BAG on pH and osmotic pressure as important factors limiting bacterial growth. MethodDifferent BAG S53P4 formulations were used for this study, including (a) powder (<45 μm), (b) granules (500–800 µm), (c) a cone-shaped scaffold and (d) two putty formulations containing granules with no powder (putty A) or with additional powder (putty B) bound together by a synthetic binder. Inert glass beads (1.0–1.3 mm) were included as control. All formulations were tested in a concentration of 1750 mg/ml in Müller-Hinton-Broth against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus epidermidis (MRSE). Vancomycin was tested at the minimum-inhibitory concentration for each strain. Changes in pH and osmolality over time were assessed at 0 h, 24 h, 72 h and 168 h. ResultsAll tested BAG formulations showed antibiofilm activity against MRSA and MRSE. Powder and putty B were the most effective formulations suppressing biofilm leading to its complete eradication after up to 168 h of co-incubation, followed by granules, scaffold and putty A. In general, MRSE appeared to be more susceptible to bioactive glass compared to MRSA. The addition of vancomycin had no substantial impact on biofilm eradication. We observed a positive correlation between a higher pH and higher antibiofilm activity. ConclusionsBAG S53P4 has demonstrated efficient biofilm antibiofilm activity against MRSA and MRSE, especially in powder-containing formulations, resulting in complete eradication of biofilm. Our data indicate neither remarkable increase nor decrease in antimicrobial efficacy with addition of vancomycin. Moreover, high pH appears to have a direct antimicrobial impact; the role of high osmolality needs further investigation.