Efficacy of calcium propionate against fungicide-resistant fungal plant pathogens and suppression of botrytis blight of ornamental flowers

Abstract

Conventional fungicides are used in IPM programs to manage fungal plant pathogens, but there are concerns about resistance development in target organisms, environmental contamination, and human health risks. This study explored the potential of calcium propionate (CaP), a common food preservative generally recognized as safe (GRAS) to control fungicide-resistant plant pathogens, mainly Botrytis cinerea, and botrytis blight in ornamentals. In-vitro experiments using mycelium growth inhibition indicated a mean EC50 value for CaP (pH 6.0) of 527 mg/L for six isolates of Botrytis cinerea as well as 618, 1354, and 1310 mg/L for six isolates each of Monilinia fructicola, Alternaria alternata, and Colletotrichum acutatum. In vitro efficacy tests indicated CaP equally inhibited mycelium growth of fungal isolates sensitive and resistant to FRAC codes 1, 2, 3, 7, 9, 11, 12, and 17 fungicides. CaP at 0.1% (pH 6.0–6.5) reduced infection cushion (IC) formation in vitro, botrytis blight on petunia flowers, and botrytis blight of cut flower roses with little to no visible phytotoxicity. Although higher concentrations strongly inhibited infection cushion formation, they did not improve efficacy and exhibited phytotoxicity. We hypothesize that high concentrations may create tissue damage that facilitates direct fungal penetration without the need for infection cushion and subsequent appressoria formation. This study indicates the potential usefulness of CaP for blossom blight disease management in ornamentals if applied at concentrations low enough to avoid phytotoxicity.