Effects of Voice Therapy for Dysphonia due to Tension Imbalance in Unilateral Vocal Fold Paralysis and Paresis

Abstract

Medialization procedures, such as type I thyroplasty, arytenoid adduction, and vocal fold injection, are popular treatments for dysphonia due to unilateral vocal fold paralysis (UVFP). However, dysphonia occasionally persists after medialization procedures owing to tension imbalance. This tension imbalance causes diplophonia, asymmetry and aperiodic vibrational flutter in travelling wave motion. Currently, there is no established treatment for tension imbalance. We herein report two cases with residual dysphonia due to tension imbalance following medialization for chronic UVFP, and another case presenting with dysphonia due to tension imbalance following chronic unilateral vocal fold paresis. Three patients underwent voice therapy using flow phonation to facilitate increased airflow management in speech as well as forward oral resonance by focusing on balanced airflow. Phonatory outcomes were evaluated using stroboscopic findings, aerodynamic and acoustic measures, as well as self-rating. Aerodynamic assessments, acoustic findings and self-ratings improved in all three cases after voice therapy. Stroboscopic findings prior to voice therapy showed asymmetric vibration with glottic gap, which was improved after voice therapy. Fundamental frequency (F0) also increased post-therapy. In a previous canine study, it was shown that enhanced breath support with expiratory airflow resulted in increased F0, suggesting that enhanced breath support could increase vocal fold tension. The increased F0 achieved in the present cases following voice therapy may increase vocal fold tension with breath support. Thus, voice therapy using flow phonation may be effective for supporting vocal fold tension and improving dysphonia due to tension imbalance following UVFP and paresis.