Effects of “Tobacco Free” Language in Warning Labels on Perceptions of Electronic Cigarettes and Nicotine Pouches among Young Adult Men: A Randomized Trial

Abstract

Background: Manufacturers of Puff Bar electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes) and Fre nicotine pouches claim that their products contain synthetic nicotine. The packages for Puff Bar and Fre have modified versions of the warning labels required by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for tobacco products, which specify that Puff Bar and Fre products contain “tobacco free” or “non-tobacco” nicotine, respectively. We evaluated whether exposure to these “tobacco free” warning labels was associated with differing perceptions about the products. Method: N = 239 young adult men who were enrolled in a cohort study completed a short online experiment. Participants were randomly assigned to view either packages of Puff Bar and Fre nicotine pouches with the standard FDA warning or packages with the standard FDA warning + the tobacco free descriptor. We compared harm and addictiveness perceptions and products’ perceived substitutability for cigarettes and smokeless tobacco (SLT) by exposure to a “tobacco free” warning. Results: Viewing a Puff Bar package with a “tobacco free” warning label was associated with increased perceived substitutability of the product for cigarettes and smokeless tobacco (p’s<.05). Viewing a Fre package with a “non-tobacco” warning label was associated with thinking the product was less harmful than SLT (p<.01). Conclusions: “Tobacco free” descriptors in warning labels for e-cigarettes and nicotine pouches affect young adults’ perceptions of the products. To date, it is unclear whether the FDA will continue to permit “tobacco free” descriptors in warning labels. As e-cigarettes and nicotine pouches are increasingly marketed with “tobacco free” language, urgent action is needed.