Effects of sclerophylly and host choice on gall densities and herbivory distribution in an Australian subtropical forest

Abstract

We hypothesize that upper canopies contrast with the understorey vegetation in gall density and survival because of greater mortality in the latter. We expect that high sclerophylly rates in the upper canopy leaves are a main cause of such pattern, and more important than other environmental traits, for instance related to altitude. The study was conducted in Lamington National Park, Queensland, Australia. Four independent vertical cylindrical transects through the forest canopy and one equivalent, horizontal understorey transect (20 m long and 1 m in diameter) were sampled at different altitude (300, 700, 900 and 1100 m above sea level) during two seasons. Total and damaged leaves were counted, and galls were collected and opened to determine if they were alive or what may have been the cause of death. Sclerophylly was estimated as specific foliar mass. Out of 72 sampled plant species, 29 presented galls, of which the greatest densities were concentrated on seven host species. A significant increase in sclerophylly with increasing canopy stratum height was observed, but had no direct effect on gall distribution. Total and live galls were more abundant in the canopy than in the understorey for all altitudes but 300 m, where a specific infestation on saplings of the canopy tree Arytera divaricata occurred. We found a positive gall establishment and survivorship in the upper canopy, along with a decrease in chewing herbivory, which resulted in decreasing risks of gall death by herbivory. An overall high sclerophylly rate in both canopy and understorey and the total number of galled host species suggest that the plant community studied is prone to gall establishment and evolution. However, a few hosts species with extreme infestation, such as A. divaricata and Ficus watkinsiana, override the community-wide effect of sclerophylly. Our results emphasize how scarce and patchy distributed galls are.