Effects of medulloblastoma resections on outcome in children: a report from the Children's Cancer Group.

Abstract

We reviewed the data of children with high-stage primitive neuroectodermal tumors (medulloblastomas) who were treated on Children's Cancer Group-921 protocol to evaluate the correlation between tumor resection and prognosis. Patients enrolled in the study had either tumors that were operatively categorized to be Chang tumor stage 3b or 4, postoperative residual tumors > 1.5 cm2, or evidence of tumor dissemination (Chang metastasis Stages [M Stages] 1-4) at diagnosis. Resections were analyzed in two ways, as follows: 1) by the extent of resection (percent of the tumor that was removed), as estimated by the treating neurosurgeon; and 2) by the extent of residual tumor (how much of the tumor was left), as estimated from postoperative scans. Two hundred and three children were enrolled in the study with institutional diagnoses of primitive neuroectodermal tumors-medulloblastomas; diagnoses were confirmed by central neuropathological review in 188 patients. Progression-free survival (PFS) at 5 years was 54% (standard error, 5%). As in previous Children's Cancer Group studies, age and M stage correlated with survival; PFS was significantly lower in children 1.5 to 3.0 years old at diagnosis and in those with any evidence of tumor dissemination (M Stage 1-4). On univariate analysis, neither extent of resection nor extent of residual tumor correlated with PFS. However, adjusting for other factors, extent of residual tumor was important; PFS was 20% (standard error, 14%) better at 5 years in children with no dissemination (M Stage 0) who had < 1.5 cm2 of residual tumor (P = 0.065) and was 24% (standard error, 14%) better at 5 years in children > 3 years old with no tumor dissemination (M Stage 0) and with < 1.5 cm2 residual tumor (P = 0.033). On the basis of our observations, we conclude that extent of tumor resection, as estimated by the neurosurgeon, does not correlate with outcome but that extent of residual tumor does correlate with prognosis in certain children (those who are > 3 years old, with no tumor dissemination). In contrast to age and M stage, the major factors associated with outcome, residual tumor is an important variable in outcome, one that neurosurgeons can control.