Effects of intercropping on soil greenhouse gas emissions - A global meta-analysis

Abstract

Diversified cropping systems, such as intercropping, have shown multifunctionality in agronomic productivity promotion, pest control, and soil health improvement. However, the intense interaction between crop species stimulates soil carbon and nitrogen turnover, and intercropping systems cause inexplicit effects on soil greenhouse gas emissions (GHG). Therefore, a comprehensive meta-analysis using 52 published articles (531 paired observations) was conducted to elucidate the effects of intercropping on soil N2O, CO2, and CH4 emissions under different environmental conditions and field practices to identify the primary driving factors, such as climate, soil and field practices. The results showed that intercropping treatment had a non-significant impact on the three GHG emissions on average. However, using a cereal-legume intercropping regime, adopting moderate N application rate or intercropping in alkaline soils could significantly mitigate soil N2O emission. Additionally, intercropping in soils with high soil organic carbon reduce soil CH4 emission. On the contrary, increasing intercropping duration, or adopted in soils with moderate soil total N tended to stimulate CO2 emission. The mixed-effect model selection indicated that initial soil pH, MAP, MAT, tillage regime, and intercropping duration and type were significant moderators in regulating soil GHG emissions. Our findings explicitly elucidated soil GHG responses to intercropping practice. Further studies are warranted on the evaluation of long-term intercropping effects to improve the comprehensive understanding of C and N balance and global warming potential under intercropping.